New
York Times (September 10,2004).
SICK OF
WORK
_files/image002.jpg)
Steven
Kuchuk, a therapist, treats many patients with stressful jobs.
For Michael
Jones, an architect at a top-tier firm in New York, juggling multiple projects
and running on four hours of sleep is business as usual. Mr. Jones has
adjusted, he says, to a rapid pace and the constant pressure that leads his
colleagues to "blow up" from time to time.
A design
project can drag on for more than a year, often requiring six-day workweeks and
painstaking effort. At the moment, he said, he is working on four.
But for Mr.
Jones, the stress is worth it, if only because every now and then he can gaze
at the Manhattan skyline and spot a product of his labor: the soaring profile
of the Chatham apartment building on East 65th Street, one of many structures
he has helped design in his 14 years at Robert A. M. Stern Architects.
"If I
didn't feel like I was part of something important, I wouldn't be able to do
this," he said.
Mr. Jones
belongs to a rare breed of worker that psychologists have struggled to
understand for decades, not for the sheer amount of stress they grapple with
day to day, but for the way they flourish under it. They are a familiar but
puzzling force in the workplace, perpetually functioning in overdrive to meet a
punishing schedule or a demanding boss.
To
colleagues, these men and women may seem simply like workaholics. But
psychologists who study them call them resilient, or hardy, and say they share
certain backgrounds and qualities that enable them to thrive under enormous
pressure.
"People
who are high in hardiness enjoy ongoing changes and difficulties," said
Dr. Salvatore R. Maddi, a professor of psychology at the University of
California, Irvine, and the author of a forthcoming book, "Resilience at
Work." "They find themselves more involved in their work when it gets
tougher and more complicated. They tend to think of stress as a normal part of
life, rather than as something that's unfair.''
Chronic
stress has been linked to an array of illnesses, including heart disease and
depression. But people who cope successfully, studies have found, punch in at
work with normal levels of stress hormones that climb during the day and drop
sharply at night. Their coworkers who complain of being too stressed have
consistently higher levels of hormones that rarely dip very far, trapping them
in a constant state of anxiety.
At the same
time, resilient people seem to avoid stress-related health and psychological
problems, even as colleagues are falling to pieces, say researchers who have
studied strenuous work environments.
"Some of
it is genetic, some of it is how you were raised, and some it is just your
personality," Dr. Bruce McEwen, director of the neuroendocrinology
laboratory at Rockefeller University, said.
People who
thrive under pressure do not necessarily seek out particular professions, researchers
say. But whether they are on the trading floor or the campaign trail, they all
appear to have had early experiences in difficult environments that taught them
how to regulate their stress levels. They can sense when they are reaching
their breaking point, and they know when to take a walk or turn off the ringer.
In some
cases, these people subject themselves to stresses of their own making, driven
by an unconscious urge to conquer pressures that dogged them as children or
young adults, said Steven Kuchuck, a psychotherapist in New York who treats
many patients who seek out demanding jobs and relationships.
"There's
this strong desire to go back to similar sources of stress that they grew up
with in an effort to master it," Mr. Kuchuck said. "Some people will
say 'No, I don't like a lot of stress,' but they find themselves in one
stressful job after another, so there must be something that's pulling
them."
Mr. Kuchuck
has also seen the opposite: people who crave a frenzied career because they feel
their childhoods were not stimulating at all.
But
regardless of what propels people to push themselves, what allows them to
prosper, psychologists say, is a strong commitment to their career, a feeling
of being in control, and a tendency to view stress as a challenge rather than
as a burden.
People's
attitudes toward their jobs and the degree to which they feel they make a
difference by showing up each day have long been considered powerful indicators
of how well they will do. Being just another cog in a machine with no say over
what happens is almost guaranteed to cause burnout. But even in the most
grueling work environment, people can cope if they feel they have some control.
Studies of
professional musicians show that people in orchestras are often less satisfied
and more stressed than those in small chamber groups because they lack
autonomy, according to Dr. Robert M. Sapolsky, a professor of biology and
neurology at Stanford and the author of "Why Zebras Don't Get
Ulcers." Orchestra musicians are at the mercy of their maestro's every
whim. For years, they had no power even to take regular bathroom breaks.
"The
people who are under someone's thumb, who are low-ranking and don't have any
decision-making,'' Dr. McEwen said, "these are the people who always
experience more anxiety."
People who
exhibit hardiness are reluctant to cede control. They are also less likely to
feel victimized by their bosses or by unpredictable life circumstances. When
there is a crisis at work, they can tough it out because they accept a harsh
workload or the occasional pink slip as an unsavory but inevitable part of
life, psychologists say.
"They
know there'll be different challenges, some you can't even anticipate, yet they
train their minds to say these things are expected," said Dr. Robert
Brooks, a clinical psychologist at Harvard Medical School and the author of
"The Power of Resilience."
Anticipating
troubled waters can decrease vulnerability to stress-induced diseases. In the
early 1980's, Dr. Maddi of U.C. Irvine followed hundreds of employees at
Illinois Bell when its parent company, AT&T, was facing federal
deregulation. More than 10,000 people eventually lost their jobs.
"There
was suicide, depression, anxiety disorders, divorces, heart attacks, strokes - all
the things that could be attributed to massive stress," Dr. Maddi said.
But while
about two-thirds of the workers in Dr. Maddi's sample unraveled, the other
third thrived. They survived the incident with their health intact and hung
onto their jobs or moved to another company where they quickly climbed up the
ranks.
When the
researchers went back and reviewed their first set of interviews, they found
that many of the people who made it through unscathed had stressful family
backgrounds - constant moving, their parents getting divorced - and were more
likely to describe change as inevitable.
"Some of
the people who cracked had initially taken a job with Bell rather than I.B.M.
because they believed it was safe and didn't want any disruption," Dr. Maddi
said.
Stress is
unavoidable, so bracing for it every now and then is the best way to cope. But
people who are on constant alert may be suffering from an anxiety disorder,
psychologists say.
Those who
collapse under the pressures of the workplace are prone to envision every
worst-case scenario, while resilient people think of how a greater workload,
for example, might lead to a promotion. In studies, researchers have found that
perhaps the only time pessimists thrive is when they become lawyers.
"If
you're drawing up a contract, the ability to see every foreseeable danger is
something that goes along with pessimism, but it's also what makes a good
lawyer," Dr. Martin Seligman, a professor of psychology at the University
of Pennsylvania, said. "The problem is, not only are they good at seeing
that the roof might collapse on you, they're also good at seeing that their
mate might be having an affair, that they're never going to make partner."
But one way
to overcome cynicism and exhaustion, said Dr. Andy Morgan, an associate
professor of psychiatry at Yale, is with a sense of personal accomplishment.
An architect
who toils six days a week, regularly burning the midnight oil, like Mr. Jones,
can be happy if a glimpse of the Manhattan skyline illustrates the value of his
efforts.
"When
you feel that you're accomplishing something, it's akin to a sense of
control," Dr. Morgan said. "When people start feeling that what
they're doing is not meaningful, then they take more sick days, begin looking
for another job, and complain of health problems."